Music for Grown-Ups® - independent . eclectic . curious - Celebrating the great musicians - from Sinatra to the Stones, Miles to Mozart, Dylan to David Bowie, Beck to Bjork, and Coltrane to Cole Porter


 

Daily Update

 

Archives

 

Manifesto

 

Books

 

Shop

 

Feedback


 

Music for Grown-Ups Newsletter
Subscribe to our FREE monthly newsletter now!

Your Email:


Find out more...

 

 

17/08/2007

Remixing Dylan, Elvis, Bob Marley, Ella, Miles, Billie Holiday et al

 

Thanks to Martin Cowan:

“Sunday's Observer Music Monthly carried Paul Morley's barbed critique of the new Dylan remix. Having heard the track myself, I find myself agreeing with him”:

http://music.guardian.co.uk/rock/comment/story/0,,2144403,00.html

There’s another view:

The Dylan remix is part of a trend of record labels attempting to reach a new audience for their heritage recordings by throwing in the odd electronica remix in otherwise faithful compilation albums.

The new track on the Dylan 3CD follows recent compilations of timeless recordings by top musicians - including Elvis, Bob Marley Ella Fitzgerald, Miles Davis and Billie Holiday – which have been treated either to a full album of remixes or a bonus track or two.

I can take them or leave them: any reinterpretation of great music is potentially interesting; some work, some don’t, but failure is no reason not to try. But I’d much prefer to listen to an electronica version of a Dylan song than yet another cover by yet another tedious, check-shirted grizzled Olde Farte brandishing an acoustic guitar.

The new remix of Most Likely You Go Your Way will have no bearing on whether I buy the new product, but I’ll give the remix at least a few hearings. As for Sony’s PR, attempting to make the remix into a big talking point – it obviously worked here, but I can’t help feeling it’s misguided – a trivial distraction from a great body of art.


Gerry Smith


 

 

[Previous entry: "Joni Mitchell's new album - lyrics and cover art"]

[Next entry: "This Week’s Music for Grown-Ups on Radio/TV"]

[Latest Daily Update]

Search entries:

Powered By Greymatter

 


Copyright © Music for Grown-Ups Ltd. 2005
The words Music for Grown-Ups® and the logo design constitute a registered trademark of Music for Grown-Ups Ltd.

www.musicforgrownups.co.uk
Email: info@musicforgrownups.co.uk

 

 

 

Have you seen
our new sister site?

The Dylan Daily

The Dylan Daily - Celebrating the art of Bob Dylan

Gigs for Grown-Ups

Recommended Recent Releases

 

[Latest Update]

[Archives]

 

[Previous entry: "Joni Mitchell's new album - lyrics and cover art"]

[Next entry: "This Week’s Music for Grown-Ups on Radio/TV"]

 

Search Archives

Top | Back

 

 

Daily Update

 

Archives

 

Manifesto

 

Books

 

Shop

 

Feedback

 

Terms & Conditions

About us

Site design by watson press website design & authoring