Music for Grown-Ups® - independent . eclectic . curious - Celebrating the great musicians - from Sinatra to the Stones, Miles to Mozart, Dylan to David Bowie, Beck to Bjork, and Coltrane to Cole Porter


 

Daily Update

 

Archives

 

Manifesto

 

Books

 

Shop

 

Feedback


 

Music for Grown-Ups Newsletter
Subscribe to our FREE monthly newsletter now!


Subscribe
Unsubscribe


Find out more...

 

 

 

30/08/2004

Folk festival horror - weekend pastoralists at play

 

If I were to be marooned in the idyllic Devon seaside resort at the time of the annual Sidmouth (folk) Festival, I'd probably lose the will to live. Surrounded by thousands of weekend pastoralists - all desperately trying to recapture a mythical Arcadia, exulting in hokum like Morris dancers and black-faced Cloggies - I'd probably decide to go for a long, long swim. The police would find a neatly arranged pile of clothes on the beach, just above the tide line.

BBC4's delightful film of this year's Sidmouth Festival (the fiftieth) didn't avoid the horrors of the contemporary folk scene.

And the film showcased some of the big cheeses in the Brit folk world - Kate Rusby, the Yorkie diva; Eliza Carthy, inheritor of the Watersons mantle; and Steeleye Span, the radicals who dared to mix precious folk with that horrid, tawdry (liberal-left code for "American") rock. The artistry of each is obvious, though none floats my boat.

But none of this detracted from the musical riches buried deep within the film. Two bands stood out. Danu played a couple of evocative Irish laments. Tiger Moth excelled with their (electric) English country dance tunes from the late 19thC. These two succeeded where most folk fails, in authentically evoking time and place, offering music which transcends the genre. Their music was intrinsically and beautifully interesting, universal in its appeal, independent of its context. (But probably wasted on this audience of bearded, cheesecloth-clad Drabbies.)

Folk music can be grown-up. As the Sidmouth film demonstrated, however, it mostly isn't: its grown-up quotient is tiny. The lyrical element of much folk music makes it so unpalatable; most of the music isn't a problem.

But, to be fair, most music in most other genres isn't really suitable for grown-ups, either.

Gerry Smith


 

 

[Previous entry: ""The Greatest Songwriters of all time""]

[Next entry: "Puccini's Gianni Schicchi - another triumph at the Proms"]

[Latest Daily Update]

Search entries:

Powered By Greymatter

 


Copyright © Music for Grown-Ups Ltd. 2005
The words Music for Grown-Ups® and the logo design constitute a registered trademark of Music for Grown-Ups Ltd.

www.musicforgrownups.co.uk
Email: info@musicforgrownups.co.uk

 

 

 

Gigs for Grown-Ups

Recommended Recent Releases

 

[Latest Update]

[Archives]

 

[Previous entry: ""The Greatest Songwriters of all time""]

[Next entry: "Puccini's Gianni Schicchi - another triumph at the Proms"]

 

Search Archives

Top | Back

 

 

Daily Update

 

Archives

 

Manifesto

 

Books

 

Shop

 

Feedback

 

Terms & Conditions

About us

Site design by watson press website design & authoring